
‘Bad Apples’ Review: Saoirse Ronan Takes School Discipline Into Her Own Hands
The Irish actress plays a beleaguered teacher who takes drastic measures against an unruly pupil in Jonatan Etzler’s dark satire of the educational system.
More than a conventional film, Bad Apples is a thought experiment, a dark satire of the educational system that challenges many of the assumptions and practices underlying the way schools operate today. It’s less a believable story than an elaborate exercise in what-if, the kind of premise that doesn’t necessarily hold up when subjected to the usual plausibility test. Almost nothing that happens here could unfold quite this way in the real world. But the interesting thing about the film, directed by Swedish filmmaker Jonatan Etzler, is precisely the way it opens up a discussion, inviting us to consider how a school — and, by extension, an entire community — might respond to the kind of crisis it puts on the table.
Saoirse Ronan plays Maria Spencer, a young teacher at an English school in a small, seemingly idyllic town. The film opens with Maria and her class visiting a cider factory to learn how apples are processed. (Yes, the metaphor is about as subtle as a sledgehammer, but subtlety isn’t exactly what this film is after.) There, we discover that Maria has a serious problem on her hands. One of her ten-year-old pupils, Danny (Eddie Waller), throws his sneaker into the production line, ruining the school trip, the cider-making process and, as far as Maria is concerned, her entire day. The boy runs off, Maria chases after him, and somehow she’s the one who ends up being reprimanded for the incident.

At a school where both administrators and parents seem to regard her with suspicion — her Irish accent marks her as an outsider, while her gentle manner is sometimes mistaken for weakness — Maria is increasingly struggling to keep things under control. The following day, Danny is back in the classroom, as aggressive, defiant and unmanageable as ever. Neither Maria nor her fellow students — and certainly not his father, who seems caught somewhere between exhaustion and indifference — can rein in this seemingly unstoppable ball of anger. Things take a turn for the worse when Danny pushes a classmate down a flight of stairs, breaking her arm. Only then is he suspended, though not before Maria is once again taken to task for her inability to control her classroom.
All the frustration Maria has been forced to swallow finally boils over when she goes to retrieve her car from a parking lot and finds Danny smashing it with a metal bar. What follows is a scuffle that quickly gets out of hand. Faced with the boy’s relentless aggression, Maria makes a decision that is both absurd and incomprehensible, yet somehow feels inevitable within her increasingly distorted frame of mind: she kidnaps him and locks him in the basement of her house. From that point on, the teacher, the pupil, the classroom, the school and the entire community must figure out how to deal with the disappearance of this «bad apple» that nobody seemed able to handle anymore.
Etzler uses this increasingly bizarre situation to question the way educational institutions deal with disruptive students, teachers who are unable to do their jobs as they would like, and an administration that would rather find someone to blame or simply get rid of a problem than actually address it, both in human and financial terms. The film’s sights extend beyond the school, though. It also takes aim at the broader community, the attitudes of parents and the behavior of the children themselves. Sharp-edged and dark, if not particularly funny (the material is simply too abrasive to generate many laughs), Bad Apples is a merciless, rather cruel satire. Its aim, however, is remarkably well-targeted.

Ronan gives Maria just the right amount of warmth and vulnerability to make her increasingly outrageous behavior understandable, at least within the context of the film. That applies not only to the kidnapping itself but also to everything that follows. Her performance helps us accept the film’s wildly improbable premise, to the point where we may find ourselves putting ourselves in her shoes and even hoping she doesn’t get caught, however brutal and irrational her actions become. Young Waller is equally effective, capturing Danny’s aggression and stubbornness while also allowing glimpses of what might be warmth, humanity or simply desperation beneath his hostile exterior.
This is not a film to be approached through the lens of logic. Almost nothing that happens would withstand even the most basic scrutiny, particularly if the police were to do their job, for starters. But Etzler, adapting Rasmus Lindgren’s Swedish novel of the same name, isn’t interested in playing by those rules. Instead, he exaggerates everything, pushing the story into the territory of a thought experiment. Etzler is ultimately turning the question back on the audience — teachers, students, parents and anyone with children of school age. What would you do if you found yourself in a situation like this? The answers might be more surprising than we’d care to admit.



