‘The Good Daughter’ Peacock Review: Rose Byrne and Meghann Fahy Elevate a Familiar Southern Legal Thriller

‘The Good Daughter’ Peacock Review: Rose Byrne and Meghann Fahy Elevate a Familiar Southern Legal Thriller

Rose Byrne and Meghann Fahy play estranged sisters and lawyers reunited by a school murder case and an attack on their father. Streaming on Peacock.

Adapted by its author from her own novel, The Good Daughter tells the story of two sisters who live through a traumatic event as teenagers, then find each other again as adults when another criminal case forces them back into the same room. The six-episode series, all of it directed by Steph Green, moves back and forth between their adult present and a past when they lived with their parents and life seemed more or less normal. The show makes it clear from the outset that this wouldn’t last.

The opening scene finds Sam and Charlotte (everyone calls her «Charlie») in a small Georgia town with their mother, Gamma (Olivia Williams), and their father, a lawyer known as Rusty (Brendan Gleeson). Two masked men break into the house, and in the confusion and chaos they kill the mother and badly injure Sam, the older sister. From there the series jumps to the present and settles in with Charlie (played as an adult by Meghann Fahy, of Sirens and Drop), a lawyer who now works alongside her father in the same town where she has spent her whole life. Sam (Rose Byrne) is a lawyer too. She carries lasting effects of that night, including a limp and neurological damage that sometimes affects her speech, and she works for a major firm in New York. Most important of all, the two haven’t spoken in ten years.

Two events bring them back together. First, Charlie becomes a witness to a crime at the school where Hank (Jake McDorman), the man she spent the previous night with, works. A teenager named Kelly (Shayna Benardo) apparently kills another girl and a teacher, and the police arrive and take her into custody while Charlie and Hank try to keep the situation from spiraling. The apparent culprit has psychiatric problems, and what happened is far from clear. Rusty takes on the case, but that same day someone stabs him (he won’t say who) and he ends up hospitalized and out of commission. That’s when Sam returns to see her father, and since Charlie can’t handle a case in which she’s a witness, Sam ends up taking it on herself.

That’s the setup for a series that moves between two timelines, and at times three, since there’s a stop in between, at the moment the sisters’ relationship fractures. As it goes, it tangles up Sam and Charlie, their family’s ties to other families in town and, above all, their dealings with the local powers that be. Rusty has always defended difficult clients, some of them guilty of terrible crimes, and he has enemies on every side. The daughters, who accused the two men who killed their mother, aren’t exactly welcome among those men’s relatives either, who insist they were innocent. Along the way there’s room for infidelity, love triangles, pregnancies, rape, legal maneuvering and other staples of the genre.

The best thing about the show is its central trio of performances, which lend the story a dramatic credibility it wouldn’t otherwise have. The script is smart enough to dig into the details of the sisters’ bond, the trauma each of them carries, their history with their mother and their friction with their father. It also slips in some unexpectedly funny moments and stretches of lightness to ease the weight of such heavy material. At its best, The Good Daughter works as a drama about two sisters who survived a pair of traumatic experiences and have each, in her own way, tried to live with them.

The weaker link is the criminal case that holds the story together. At one point it splits in two and ends up opening the door to a reexamination of the past case, the murder of Sam and Charlie’s mother. False leads, assorted coincidences, conveniently timed arrivals and other genre tricks pile up into something that never quite comes together. So much so that the resolution of the cases, with the exception of a few specific details, ends up as more of a narrative obstacle than a guide, a mechanical device of the kind these novels and series always rely on rather than a conflict with any interest of its own, no matter how many connections Slaughter draws between what happened then, what is happening now and the consequences of each crime.

The series won’t stay with you in a sea of similar shows that lean, somewhat repetitively, on trauma, flashbacks and revelations tied to long-buried events. At most, what will linger is what Slaughter managed to capture about the bond between two sisters who survive a traumatic experience: a mix of guilt, fear, devotion and shared anguish that stays with them for life.