‘Guarding Stars’ Netflix Review: A Holiday Romance Disguised as an Action Comedy

‘Guarding Stars’ Netflix Review: A Holiday Romance Disguised as an Action Comedy

A Hollywood star’s Christmas visit home gets complicated when his new bodyguard poses as his girlfriend to keep an obsessive stalker at bay. Streaming on Netflix.

A Christmas movie designed to ease viewers into the holiday season on the streaming platforms, Guarding Stars may dress itself up as an action rom-com, but that’s really just a collection of narrative devices meant to keep casual viewers entertained before steering them, sooner or later, toward the inevitable family reunion around the Christmas tree, complete with matching festive sweaters.

At first, it looks like one of those romantic comedies that unfolds against a suspenseful backdrop, with two people who initially seem to have very little time for each other. Based on Katherine Center’s novel The Bodyguard, the film follows Hannah Brooks (Leighton Meester), a highly skilled former military operative turned bodyguard who gets assigned a job she couldn’t care less about: protecting movie star Jack Stapleton (Jared Padalecki), who’s being stalked by an obsessive fan. The studio behind his upcoming film is understandably keen to keep him safe, whatever it takes.

Hannah, who has absolutely no idea who Jack is, is sent to Montana with a team of security professionals (who, unlike her, are familiar with the actor, and one of them is a genuine fan). Jack is spending a few days with his family for Christmas, and the plan is to keep his presence in town under wraps. No unexpected visits from the stalker, thank you very much. The catch is that Hannah has to blend into the family gathering, which means posing as Jack’s new girlfriend. His relatives, who know nothing about the security concerns and don’t seem particularly interested in protecting Jack’s privacy, keep dragging him into public situations. Hannah’s job is to make sure nobody finds out that he’s there, let alone that an entire security team is keeping an eye on him.

Of course, all of this is little more than a plot contrivance (and one that could actually have been put to much better use) designed to set up what we all know is coming: Hannah and Jack gradually discovering that they have more in common than either initially imagined. That’s when the traumas, illnesses, old regrets and family baggage start piling up. We learn considerably more about Jack’s troubled past than Hannah’s, partly because his family is practically a co-star in the film. Among them is none other than Andie MacDowell, playing his mother, a central figure in the actor’s life.

Guarding Stars throws in the occasional action sequence and an unexpected plot twist or two, but there’s not much else to it. This is a full-fledged Christmas movie, steeped in the season’s atmosphere, with the requisite costumes, music, production design and familiar holiday rituals. The premise might have led somewhere considerably more interesting, perhaps along the lines of those ’90s action rom-coms like True Lies or Last Action Hero, where the interplay between reality and fiction becomes central to the characters and their relationships. Here, however, the fact that Jack is an action movie star is barely explored beyond the obvious. It’s just another piece of information in a movie that’s short on ideas but, to its credit, overflowing with tinsel, Christmas pajamas and matching outfits.